What the Nouvelles Étoiles Jury Evaluates: Five Musical Criteria
What does a music competition jury listen for beyond correct notes? Nouvelles Étoiles publishes five evaluation criteria: technical level, respect for stylistic characteristics, difficulty of the chosen programme, artistic qualities and expression. Together, they invite candidates to think about a performance as a complete musical statement.
The published system allocates up to 20 points to each criterion, for a maximum of 100. The explanations below are editorial listening examples, not additional rules, scoring instructions or statements from individual jurors.
Technical level: making an intention audible
Think of a passage in which the melody moves gently while the accompaniment remains active. Technical control allows those two roles to stay distinct. In another piece, the challenge might be an even sequence of notes, a clear articulation or a reliable change of register. A useful musical question is whether the chosen effect comes across clearly, rather than whether the passage merely looks impressive on the page.
Style: understanding the language of the piece
A dance, a lyrical song and a dramatic recitative ask different things of a performer. Their rhythms, phrase shapes and articulations do not need to be treated identically. Discuss the work’s context with your teacher and return to the score when considering an interpretative choice. The aim is to make informed decisions about the particular music you are presenting, rather than apply the same expressive gestures everywhere.
Programme difficulty: challenge within a complete performance
Difficulty is one published criterion among five. A demanding title alone does not explain how a performance will communicate. Consider the whole work: its quieter passages, transitions and sustained musical lines may be as revealing as its fastest section. When discussing repertoire, distinguish between being able to attempt the notes and being ready to present a convincing interpretation from beginning to end.
Artistic qualities: giving the performance a direction
Imagine hearing a piece without seeing its score. Where does the music seem to be going? Which moments feel like an arrival, a question or a return? These are useful ways to explore the shape of an interpretation. A small detail can have a larger purpose: a change in colour may introduce a new idea, while a carefully paced transition can connect two contrasting sections.
Expression: communicating character through sound
Expression can be explored through phrasing, timing, dynamics and tone colour. It need not mean making every contrast larger. Try describing the character of a phrase in a few words, then listen to whether the sound conveys that idea. Two thoughtful interpretations may differ; the task is to make your own choices coherent and audible.
Read the criteria together
These five perspectives overlap in the act of performing. Control supports expression; an understanding of style informs artistic choices. Use the published criteria as a starting point for a musical conversation with your teacher, not as a promise of a particular score or prize. The official rules remain the reference for the competition.




Comments